Bakery

It’s always pie heaven here on the farm…treat yourself to a delicious dessert from our bakery.

Now taking orders for delicious holiday pies & baked goods!

Choose your favorite pie:

Pie Varieties: Pumpkin, Apple, Caramel Apple Walnut, Dutch Apple, Blueberry, Coconut Custard, Cherry Crumb, Strawberry/Rhubarb, No Sugar Blueberry, No Sugar Apple.
If you’ve read through this list, you KNOW we take our pies seriously!

Although apple and pumpkin pies are the seasonal favorites, our bakery also sells other pies, pastries, danish, cookies and our signature cider donuts smothered in cinnamon & sugar for those who want to bring some variety to their holiday table.

Our freshly baked cider donuts are famous and delicious.

Treat yourself to a variety of muffins, some rich and decadent butter cookies or try the many other delicious baked goods:

Cookies: Chocolate Chip, Shortbread

Strudel Stix: Strawberry/Cream, Apple

Pumpkin Roll: With Cream Cheese

Apple Dumplin’: Delicious!

Danish: Meltaway, Cheese, Blueberry, Raspberry, Almond, Poppyseed

Teabread: Pumpkin, Banana Nut, Apple Caramel, Zucchini Nut, Cinnamon

All types/flavors are subject to availability.

Homemade ice cream in season from local creamery. Read more…

Stop by the bakery at Heaven Hill Farm in Sussex County’s Vernon, New Jersey near the following Northern NJ / Orange County NY towns: Andover, Augusta, Branchville, Cranberry Lake, Franklin , Fredon, Glenwood, Hamburg, Hardyston, Highland Lakes, Hopatcong, Lafayette, Lake Mohawk, Layton, McAfee, Newton, Montague, Ogdensburg, Sparta, Stanhope, Stillwater, Stockholm, Sussex, Vernon, Walpack, Wantage, Waywayanda New Jersey (NJ), and Amity, Bellvale, Chester, Cornwall on Hudson, Florida, Goshen, Greenville, Greenwood Lake, Harriman, Middletown, Minisink, Monroe, Montgomery, New Hampton, New Milford, Newburgh, New Windsor, Pine Island, Port Jervis, Sparrow Bush, Sterling Forest, Stony Ford, Sugar Loaf, Tuxedo, Tuxedo Park, Unionville, Warwick, Washingtonville, Westtown, Woodbury New York (NY)